Buying Guide
How to Choose Cigars as a Gift
To choose cigars as a gift, match his usual strength, pick a popular size like a robusto, buy from a reputable shop and keep the cigars humidified until you give them.
Updated · Men Cigar Gifts Editorial Team
Build a Cigar Gift Set →
Picking cigars as a gift is easier than it looks. You don't need to be an expert — you need to know a little about the person and a little about how cigars differ. Here's a simple framework.
Step 1: Find Out What He Smokes
The best clue is what he already enjoys. Look for cigar bands in his ashtray or humidor, or ask a friend or partner. If you know a brand or line he likes, a tobacconist can suggest something similar or a step up.
Step 2: Match the Strength
| Strength | Typical wrapper | Good for |
|---|---|---|
| Mild | Connecticut shade (light tan) | Beginners, morning smokers |
| Medium | Habano, Corojo, Sumatra | Most smokers; the safest gift choice |
| Full | Maduro, Oscuro, heavy ligero filler | Experienced smokers who like bold cigars |
Wrapper color is only a rough guide to strength — the filler matters too — but it is a useful starting point. Our sister site explains cigar wrapper types in more detail.
Quick answer: If you don't know his taste, choose medium-bodied cigars in a robusto size (about 5 × 50) from a well-known maker. They suit the widest range of smokers.
Step 3: Choose a Size
The robusto (about 5 inches by 50 ring gauge) is the safest size: popular, about an hour to smoke, and easy to find. If he is often short on time, a petit corona or petit robusto works well; if he enjoys long evenings, a toro or Churchill. See the full cigar size chart.
Step 4: Decide How Many
- One to three cigars: a thoughtful add-on to another gift.
- A five-cigar sampler: lets him try several blends.
- A full box: best when you know his favorite cigar.
Step 5: Keep Them Fresh
Premium cigars need about 65–70% humidity. If you buy cigars more than a day or two before giving them, store them in a sealed bag with a two-way humidity pack, away from heat and sunlight. Cigars left loose in a drawer can dry out and crack.
Step 6: Buy From a Reputable Shop
A licensed tobacconist will verify age, store cigars properly and can recommend options if you describe what he likes. Be wary of very cheap "premium" cigars from unknown sellers; counterfeits of famous brands exist. Remember that tobacco products should only be gifted to adults 21 and over.
Common Gift-Buying Mistakes
- Buying by price alone. The most expensive cigar is not always the best fit; strength and size matter more.
- Going too strong. Full-bodied cigars can overwhelm a casual smoker. Medium is the safer default.
- Letting them dry out. Cigars bought weeks ahead and left unprotected can crack or burn harshly.
- Flavored when he smokes traditional. Many premium smokers prefer unflavored cigars; check first.
Questions to Ask a Tobacconist
- "He usually smokes this brand. What's similar, or a step up?"
- "What medium-bodied robusto do most of your customers enjoy?"
- "What's a good sampler for someone who likes trying new cigars?"
- "Can you include a humidity pack so they stay fresh?"
Pair the cigars with a useful accessory for a complete gift — see cigar gift sets — or browse gifts by budget.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I choose cigars as a gift?
Find out what he usually smokes, match the strength, choose a popular size such as a robusto, buy from a reputable shop and keep the cigars humidified until you give them.
What is a safe cigar to give as a gift?
A medium-bodied robusto from a well-known maker suits the widest range of cigar smokers.
How many cigars should I give?
One to three cigars make a good add-on, a five-cigar sampler lets him try several blends, and a full box is best when you know his favorite.
How do I keep gift cigars fresh?
Store them in a sealed bag with a two-way humidity pack at about 65 to 70 percent humidity, away from heat and sunlight.
Does wrapper color show cigar strength?
Only roughly. Lighter wrappers are often milder and darker wrappers often fuller, but the filler blend also determines strength.


